
MICE CREAMERY! Former Worker Leaks Stomach-Turning Photos of Pest Infestation and Gnawed Food at Closing Smith Street Newport Creamery
PROVIDENCE, R.I. — Locals mourning the sudden closure of the iconic Newport Creamery on Smith Street might want to put down their spoons—and hold their stomachs.
A former employee has blown the lid off the Elmhurst neighborhood staple, unleashing a gallery of stomach-turning photos and videos that paint the shuttered eatery not as a beloved family diner, but as a full-blown rodent buffet.
In a viral social media exposé, ex-staffer Hailey Evans told devastated fans of the chain’s famous “Awful Awful” milkshakes that they are “not missing out on anything” following the location’s shutdown. Instead, she claimed the kitchen behind the counter was a “toxic, disarrayed and contaminated” nightmare.
The photographic evidence shared online is enough to make any regular lose their appetite:

-
Uninvited Kitchen Guests: One snapshot shows a mouse scurrying along the grimy tile floor directly beside a black pest-control trap, while another image reveals a rodent tucked inside the mechanical housing of a commercial refrigerator unit.
-
Rodent-Gnawed Bread: In a video clip showing bags of hamburger buns and sliced bread on a prep table, Evans points out visible bite marks chewed right through the packaging and into the rolls, captioning the footage, “These are nibbled on.”

Past-Due Dairy: Another photo taken inside the Elmhurst location shows a staffer holding up a half-gallon jug of Garelick Farms half-and-half sporting a sell-by date that had already passed.

The whistleblower’s post—which included more than two dozen additional images of questionable kitchen conditions—has quickly circulated among shocked Rhode Islanders, turning nostalgia for the long-running Smith Street spot into collective relief that the doors are officially locked.

