
AWFUL, AWFUL! NEWPORT CREAMERY FLEES SMITH STREET AS SOCIALIST WAVE CHILLS PROVIDENCE
Iconic ice cream parlor pulls the plug on capital city location amid skyrocketing wage demands, sanctuary city policies, and a looming City Hall shakeup
PROVIDENCE, R.I. — The scoop is officially out, and it’s a bitter pill for Rhode Island traditionalists to swallow: Newport Creamery is abandoning its longtime Smith Street outpost, leaving the capital city without a single spot to grab an “Awful Awful” milkshake.
While corporate brass politely blamed the “size and age” of the historic building for the November 25 shutdown, critics and regular booth-warmers say the writing has been on the wall—and on the ballot—for months.
The shuttering of the 673 Smith Street staple comes on the heels of a political earthquake in Providence: the landslide election of 27-year-old Democratic Socialist David Morales. With the incoming mayor preparing to take the reins at City Hall on a platform of aggressive progressive reforms, local business watchers are sounding the alarm that old-school family restaurants are being priced—and pushed—out of town.
“You don’t need a crystal ball to see why a classic burger-and-shake joint is packing its bags,” said one longtime Smith Hill regular nursing a final coffee at the counter. “Between nonstop calls to jack up the minimum wage, spiraling operating costs, and a City Hall that cares more about ideological crusades than keeping the sidewalks clean and safe, small-margin businesses don’t stand a chance.”
For months, business owners across the capital have warned that aggressive wage mandates and rigid labor regulations threaten to turn a $15 milkshake into a luxury item. Meanwhile, frustration has boiled over among neighborhood residents regarding Providence’s sanctuary city policies and a visible surge in homelessness and street disorder—issues critics argue have strained municipal resources and driven away foot traffic from family-friendly corridors like Smith Street.
Instead of pouring money into modernizing the Providence location, Newport Creamery’s new ownership group—which took over the nearly century-old chain earlier this year—decided to cut its losses in the capital city alongside a simultaneous closure in Fall River, Massachusetts. The company insists it plans to unveil new locations in 2027, though conspicuously absent from its comeback roadmap is any mention of returning to Providence.
As the grills go cold on Smith Street, the closure marks more than just the end of an era for local ice cream lovers. To skeptics of Providence’s sharp turn to the left, it’s the first major casualty of a new political reality—one where even an Ocean State institution can’t afford to stick around.

